Featured GamePS4

Mafia: Definitive Edition (PS4)

Mafia: Definitive Edition, a remake of the 2002 game Mafia, appropriately aims to offer the kind of experience you’d hope to find in a game about working for the mob. You’ll be shooting tommy guns, outrunning the cops in classic cars, getting into gunfights with other bootleggers, and working your way up through the ranks of the Mafia but learning the cost of a life of crime. Not afraid to hide its influences but also throwing in some bombastic ideas to give this familiar story some exciting deviations, Mafia: Definitive Edition looks to refine Mafia into an even better representation of being a gangster in video game form.

 

The story of Mafia: Definitive Edition is told by the protagonist Tommy Angelo, a man meeting with a police detective later in life as he wants to get out of his life of crime. Once just a taxi driver, he gets recruited by gunpoint to help some mafiosos flee from some rival mobsters from the Morello family.  Not only does he impress as a wheelman, the Morello mafia isn’t keen to let him leave peacefully after, forcing him into the hands of the Salieri family. Tommy’s originally fully on board with working for Don Salieri though, proving to be good with a gun even if he shies away from some of the more brutal parts of the mobster life. Set initially in the Prohibition era in a fictional city called Lost Heaven that feels like a mix of New York City and Chicago, Tommy’s tale takes place over quite a few years, something that makes the sometimes explosive and intense campaign missions more believable since you not only wouldn’t be fighting huge battles with cops and mobsters often, but you’ll need time to lie low after. It also helps to make some of the personal relationships feel deeper since they go beyond what we immediately see. Tommy becomes fast friends with Paulie and Sam, Sam the more professional type but cold and ruthless when needed while Paulie is more clearly unhinged but also lively and fun to be around when you’re in his good books. Tommy is a bit basic by comparison which makes his romance and other moments feel a little thinner, but there is plenty of drama as the battle between crime families heats up and loyalties are tested.

The story does not shy away from acknowledging that even supposedly moral mobsters like the Salieri family get their hands very dirty, even if you’re never going to be the one shaking people down for money. You hear Paulie and Sam talking casually about some brutal actions or have moments where someone you know feels the weight of their immoral actions, and a few missions along the way help to sow the seeds of Tommy eventually wanting to get out of the mob life as he sees how it tears apart the people who devote their life to it. Even as it weaves that narrative theming into a few important missions, Mafia: Definitive Edition doesn’t forget to make the action varied and unique. While there will certainly be skirmishes around the city or countryside, you’ll get varied locations like an airport, bordello, steamship, and farm to have your gunfights in while often needing to escape through waves of mobsters and cops.

 

The city itself is a frequent piece of the action, some car chases leaving the open layout of the city to be used as you see fit to escape, although driving between missions can often just be a relaxed chance to listen in on character chatter. It’s not too surprising to see the game has an option to skip the car rides, but the driving in Mafia: Definitive Edition is fairly satisfying despite not being too permissive. Cars don’t handle perfectly since they are vehicles from the 1930s and 40s and if you ram into something like a streetlight or planter it will bring your car to a stop rather than the object being blown away like it might be in a Grand Theft Auto game. Car chases, either as someone firing at enemies from behind or trying to shake them, end up a bit more textured since you need to carefully take turns and avoid more than just traffic. When playing the story though, while you can drive wherever you please during certain sections, the plot mostly continues forward without much else to do off the beaten path. A Free Ride mode does open up where you can drive around town to search for collectibles or mess around, provoking the cops for excitement or engaging in some Free Ride only sidequests that include a few fanciful ones that embrace that mode’s less serious nature. All of this while the radio plays some real world classic tunes from the time period and the city itself cuts an impressive profile with many streets catching your eye as an interesting piece of the old school urban jungle.

 

A minimap in the corner does help with navigating to destinations, but street corners also have temporary sign markers indicating the turn so you don’t need to rely on it, the driving generally finding a great spot in terms of authenticity and video game convenience, although that doesn’t make the infamous Fair Play race any easier should you choose Classic Mode. Classic hues more towards the original 2002 Mafia with elements like guns being far more lethal, cops being more watchful for even minor crimes, and vehicles being more fragile, but the racing mission notably contains a shift in control away from even the standard cars in an already tight competition. The mission probably won’t stand out much in the regular difficulty, but Classic exists as a more realistic if more brutal alternative if you really want to steep yourself in the mobster life, warts and all.

The shooting during regular play in Mafia: Definitive Edition already has some interesting compromises to keep it from being too easy but still enjoyable to participate in. While the weapon variety is rather small with mostly just pistols, a tommy gun, and a shotgun, plus the rare sniper rifle and an assortment of melee weapons like bats and daggers, guns are limited well in a few ways. When pointing your weapon, the target reticle often shows a ring that indicates the expected area of where you’re aiming, but it’s not too precise. You may have the head of a mobster in your sights, but the bullet can deviate anywhere within that ring, making it so it’s not a guaranteed instant kill. Ammo is limited so you need to pick your shots and line them up well too account for this, and Mafia: Definitive Edition is a cover shooter so you’ll want to hunker down behind something while your foes are trying to do the same. Popping out and trying to line your shot up is crucial to survival, but your life isn’t too abundant either. You can get worn down fairly quickly, and while you do automatically recover a bit of health once you hit the lowest limits, it’s not going to let you play foolishly. Even outside of Classic mode you have to treat foes as fairly lethal threats and weapons like shotguns can be devastating if you let a guy get the drop on you with one. Hiding behind cover and waiting for enemies to pop out can be slow sometimes even though the game does scatter some tools like molotovs to throw or explosive barrels to keep it from constantly slowing down, and if you get in a melee fight it can feel rather stiff where it’s mostly about pressing triangle to dodge their first attack and then whaling away and hoping you do enough to finish them off before another dodge is needed.

 

Some sections are a bit more open to stealth, letting you try and clear out enemies before triggering the big fight, although moments where it is required can be testy since raising the alarm is an automatic failure. Moments like that and the racing mission do keep the game from blending together too much despite the area variety, although it is surprising that the early game can go fairly good stretches without proper gunfights. I did notably get an inexplicable bug where a blast of extremely loud noise played for a while near a warehouse and a game reset was required since many of the sound effects were disabled afterwards, but that was one of the few moments that truly could take you out of a well-crafted world that even includes concurrent real world events like the Great Depression and lead-up to World War II to make its fictional city feel like a part of reality.

THE VERDICT: A well-told tale of the exciting highs and painful lows of life in the mob, Mafia: Definitive Edition gives you the drama of an uncertain life of crime but the thrills of action in the city. Lost Heaven is a great host for it all, providing unique settings for the gunfights and car chases that make good use of limitations so firing and driving aren’t too easy. The cover system and stealth sections can slow things down a fair bit and Free Ride doesn’t have as much extra to do of note, but the main story provides a memorable mafia narrative with big action set pieces between the personal moments.

 

And so, I give Mafia: Definitive Edition for PlayStation 4…

A GOOD rating. While Tommy isn’t the most captivating protagonist, the company he keeps helps you feel the fun of being part of a successful mob but also start to see the toll when the people you trust turn on you or pay a terrible price for living on the wrong side of the law. You get those moments of dread because you do come to like characters like Paulie and the mob’s armorer Vinnie and can’t be certain of their safety or if they’re going to lean a different way on who they’re loyal to. The story does a good job pacing itself to give new mission types that might involve a bit of infiltration or a driving segment on top of the eventually frequent firefights, and while some of that experimentation doesn’t come out the cleanest, it helps ease up the burden on the cover shooting since those segments can drag a little when you’re hunkering down so often and can be set back by deaths that aren’t going to be too rare. The limits on accuracy and driving ease are effective parts despite taking some adjustment, a player who might be bothered by the inaccurate aiming reticle likely able to find the way to get reliable enough headshots before the game reaches its close, you just need to better position and carefully line up your shots rather than expecting leniency. It is a bit of a shame there isn’t more to do outside of the main story, meaning Free Ride isn’t able to take as much advantage of the well designed city of Lost Heaven as you might like, but a few extra quests make it at least worth checking out and their willingness to get a little strange means you’re not just signing up for more of the same.

 

While it clearly takes notes from The Godfather and other mob stories of note, Mafia: Definitive Edition still can pull you into its version of the classic story of a crime family’s rise to power and how it can fracture under its own weight. It has the space to mix up the action as you deal with cops and mobsters alike and even concocts some good reasons to break away from the usual forms of play, so while its simple name sets you up for a classic mafia experience, Mafia: Definitive Edition fleshes it out into something that has its own story beats and action thrills so it isn’t forgotten over the inspirations it pays tribute to.

One thought on “Mafia: Definitive Edition (PS4)”

  • Gooper Blooper

    I like how the Related section is just a bunch of other games that also claim to be Definitive Editions.

    Reply

Please leave a comment! I'd love to hear what you have to say!